Call or WhatsApp +91 96259 61599 advocates@legals365.com Private law firm website, not the official CAT website
Central Administrative Lawyer, B.K. Singh & Associates

Probation Extended Again and Again: When Confirmation Becomes Due

Probation extended more than once? What central probation extension rules allow, the double-period limit, deemed confirmation and how to press for a decision.

RecruitmentBy Advocate B.K. SinghUpdated 30 October 202618 min read

Probation Extended Again and Again: When Confirmation Becomes Due

In short. Probation extension rules for central government employees say the decision on your probation should come within six to eight weeks after the period ends, extensions should normally be a year at a time at most, and no one should stay on probation beyond double the normal period. This guide is for direct recruits and promotees whose probation keeps getting extended, or who have heard nothing at all. If you are past the normal period, ask in writing for a decision and for the reasons; if you are past double, take advice promptly.

सारांश (हिंदी में)केंद्रीय सरकारी कर्मचारियों के लिए परिवीक्षा (प्रोबेशन) के नियम कहते हैं कि अवधि पूरी होने के छह से आठ सप्ताह के भीतर निर्णय होना चाहिए, एक बार में आम तौर पर एक साल से अधिक विस्तार नहीं होना चाहिए, और कुल अवधि सामान्य अवधि के दोगुने से अधिक नहीं होनी चाहिए। यह लेख उन सीधी भर्ती और पदोन्नत कर्मचारियों के लिए है जिनका प्रोबेशन बार बार बढ़ाया जा रहा है या जिन्हें कोई आदेश नहीं मिला। सामान्य अवधि बीत चुकी है तो लिखित में निर्णय और कारण माँगें। दोगुनी अवधि भी पार हो गई हो तो जल्दी सलाह लें, क्योंकि आगे CAT का रास्ता खुला है।

Is this your situation?

  • Your probation period under the recruitment rules has ended, but no order declaring completion has been issued.
  • Your probation has been extended once, twice or more, with little or no reason given.
  • You were never warned in writing that your work or conduct was unsatisfactory.
  • You took long leave during probation and are unsure whether it can be added on.
  • A training course or departmental test was made a condition of completing probation, and it has not been held.
  • Colleagues from your batch have been confirmed and you have not.
  • You worry that the next order may be a discharge rather than a confirmation.

In short

  • Find the normal period first. It is fixed by the recruitment rules of your post, often one or two years, and every other limit is measured from it.
  • Six to eight weeks is the expected decision time. DoPT's 2014 instructions say the appointing authority should decide soon after probation ends, within six to eight weeks.
  • Double the normal period is the ceiling in the instructions. Extensions should normally be no more than a year at a time, and total probation should not run beyond twice the normal period.
  • Silence does not usually mean confirmation. The instructions say you continue on probation until a written order; deemed confirmation arises mainly where the service rules themselves fix a maximum.
  • A warning should come before an adverse decision. A probationer not doing well should be told in writing and given time to improve.
  • Ask for reasons in writing. A reasoned extension can be answered; an unexplained one is easier to question before the tribunal.

Where your probation period and its limits come from

Probation for central government posts is governed first by the recruitment rules of your post and then by DoPT's consolidated instructions on probation and confirmation, issued by OM No. 28020/1/2010-Estt.(C) dated 21 July 2014. Where the recruitment rules say something different from the instructions, the recruitment rules prevail. So the first document to read is not a circular but the rules of your own cadre, usually notified in the Gazette and often available on the department's website.

The recruitment rules will tell you the period of probation for direct recruits and, where it applies, for promotees. Many Group B and Group C posts carry two years for direct recruits. Some posts carry one year, some Group A services carry longer periods, and some promotion posts carry no probation at all. Your offer of appointment usually repeats the figure.

Probation applies to direct recruits, to those promoted from one group to another, and to some re-employed officers, as the instructions explain. It exists so the department can judge your fitness to be retained. That purpose matters, because an extension that serves no assessment purpose, such as one passed only because the file was never put up, is harder for a department to defend.

Probation extension rules at a glance

QuestionWhat DoPT's instructions provideWhere to check for your post
How long is probation?As fixed in the recruitment rules of the postRecruitment rules; offer of appointment
When should a decision come?Soon after the period ends, ordinarily within six to eight weeksOM of 21 July 2014; any later DoPT consolidation
How long can one extension be?Normally not more than a year at a time, save for exceptional reasonsOM of 21 July 2014
Maximum probation overall?Never more than double the normal periodOM of 21 July 2014; recruitment rules may fix their own limit
Can leave be added on?If leave stopped you completing 75 per cent of the period, probation may be extended by the leave taken, within the double limitOM of 5 October 2017
Is confirmation automatic?No; it needs a formal order, and you are treated as continuing on probation until thenOM of 21 July 2014; service rules of your cadre
How often are you confirmed?Only once in service, in the entry gradeOM of 21 July 2014

Maximum probation: what 'double the normal period' really means

DoPT's instructions say probation should not be extended by more than a year at a time except for exceptional reasons, and that in no circumstance should an employee be kept on probation for more than double the normal period. For a two-year probation, that means four years in all. For a one-year probation, two.

Departments sometimes treat the double limit as an allowance rather than a ceiling, extending by six months, then another six months, then a year, without any assessment in between. The instructions expect each extension to be based on an actual review of your work, with a reason. If the extension orders in your file all carry the same one-line text, that pattern is worth noting.

Past the double limit, the department has to choose. It can declare probation complete, or it can discharge you, subject to the safeguards for probationers. What it should not do is leave you hanging. Whether you can claim to be confirmed automatically is a separate legal question, taken up below.

Leave, training and tests that stretch probation

Long leave during probation is the most common lawful reason for an extension. DoPT's OM of 5 October 2017 says that where a probationer has not completed 75 per cent of the prescribed period because of leave of any kind, probation may be extended by the length of the leave taken, but the total still cannot exceed double. A woman officer who took maternity leave and child care leave in her first year may therefore find her probation extended, but only by the leave actually taken. Our guide on leave and posting protections for women employees deals with the leave side.

Training and tests are the second reason. The 2014 instructions allow recruitment rules to make completion of a training programme or passing a departmental test a condition of probation. Direct recruits must also go through induction training of at least two weeks under a DoPT memorandum of 11 March 2019. If the department did not hold the course or the test, the delay is its own, and an extension blamed on your not passing an exam that was never conducted can be questioned.

Check what your service book shows. Leave entries, training attendance and the date of joining all feed into the calculation, and errors in them are common. Our guide on service book mistakes in joining and leave entries explains how to get them corrected.

Deemed confirmation: when silence counts and when it does not

Many employees believe that once the probation period ends without an order, they are confirmed. In central government service that is usually wrong. The 2014 instructions say confirmation is not automatic, must follow a formal order, and until that order the employee is deemed to continue on probation. Courts generally accept this where the rules do not fix an outer limit.

The Supreme Court has recognised an exception. In State of Punjab v. Dharam Singh (1968), the rules fixed a maximum probation period and barred extension beyond it. The employee was continued beyond that maximum without an order, and the Court held he must be taken to have been confirmed. In High Court of M.P. v. Satya Narayan Jhavar (2001), the Court grouped the cases: where rules fix no maximum, there is no deemed confirmation; where they fix a maximum and forbid going beyond, continuing in service past it amounts to confirmation; and where the rules also require a specific act such as passing a test, that condition must be met first.

So the question for you is precise. Do the recruitment rules or service rules of your post, as opposed to a DoPT memorandum, fix a maximum period beyond which probation cannot go? Does any condition such as a test remain unmet? The answer decides whether a deemed confirmation argument is open, or whether your remedy is to press for a decision. Tribunals have differed on whether the double-period limit in executive instructions has the same effect as a statutory maximum, so take advice before building a case on it alone.

Probation completion order and confirmation order: what you should receive

Under the present system, the order declaring that you have successfully completed probation in the entry grade is, in effect, your confirmation. DoPT's instructions say confirmation happens only once in an employee's service, in the entry grade. A later promotion does not need a fresh confirmation, though a promotion post may carry its own probation where the recruitment rules say so.

The confirmation order matters more than people think. Some recruitment rules make completion of probation a condition for sitting in departmental examinations, for being considered for promotion, or for certain postings and deputation. A delay of two years in your order can quietly cost you a promotion cycle, even if your work was never in question.

If you change cadres by direct recruitment, for example from a Group C post to a Group B post through an open examination, you will normally serve a fresh probation in the new post. That is not an extension of your old probation, and it does not affect your confirmation in the earlier entry grade.

Advocate B.K. Singh's first tip: ask the question the file has to answer

When a probationer comes to him with a third extension order, Advocate B.K. Singh first asks to see what assessment was done before each extension. The instructions expect probation reports covering the whole period to be considered by a board of senior officers. If the file shows no such meeting, or a meeting that looked only at a pending vigilance complaint, the extension has a visible weakness.

His practical suggestion is to write a short letter to the appointing authority asking three things: the date your probation was due to end, the reasons for each extension, and whether any shortcomings were recorded. File an RTI application alongside it for the probation reports and the board's minutes. Our guide on using RTI for DPC minutes and APARs shows how to word such a request.

Extended without a warning: why that matters

The 2014 instructions say a probationer who is not making satisfactory progress should be told so in writing, with the shortcomings named and a time given to improve. Discharge is described as a severe and final step, and the instructions expect the probationer to get a chance to improve before it is taken. The same reasoning applies, with less force, to repeated extensions.

If your file has no warning letter, no adverse APAR and no counselling note, and your probation has still been extended twice, the department may struggle to explain what it was assessing. Ask to see your APARs for the period. Every APAR entry must be communicated with a chance to represent under Dev Dutt (2008) and Sukhdev Singh (2013), and an uncommunicated adverse grading cannot fairly be the silent basis for an extension. Our page on APAR grading below benchmark covers the representation route.

The opposite case also arises. Where the real reason for extending probation is a complaint or an incident, and the department is avoiding a disciplinary inquiry by keeping you on probation, the extension may be the first step towards a discharge founded on misconduct. That needs early advice, because a discharge which is in substance a punishment requires an inquiry under Article 311 and the CCS (CCA) Rules; our page on probationer discharge cases sets out the tests tribunals apply.

What a good representation on probation looks like

Keep it to two pages. Open with your name, post, office, date of joining and the probation period under the recruitment rules, with the rule quoted. Then give the dates in a short sequence: when the normal period ended, each extension order and the period it covered, and any leave you took. A reader in the establishment section should be able to see the whole history in under a minute.

Next, state what is missing. If no reasons were given for an extension, say so. If no warning or adverse entry was communicated to you, say that too. If a training course or test that the rules require was never conducted, name it and the dates on which it should have been held. Avoid adjectives and complaints about individuals; the officer who reads your letter may not be the one who caused the delay.

End with a specific request: that the competent authority decide on completion of your probation, and if it proposes any other course, that it give you the reasons and a chance to respond. Attach copies of the orders you refer to, number the pages, and send it through your controlling officer with an advance copy to the appointing authority. A clear letter of this kind also becomes the first annexure if you later need to approach the tribunal, so it is worth writing carefully.

Papers to collect before you write or file

  • Offer of appointment and joining report, showing the date your probation began.
  • Recruitment rules of your post, with the probation clause marked.
  • Every extension order, with the date of issue and the period it covers.
  • Leave orders and leave account for the probation period.
  • Training certificates and any departmental test results or notices.
  • APARs for the probation period, or your request for them.
  • Any warning letter, memo or counselling note, and your replies.
  • Confirmation or completion orders of batchmates, if you can get them lawfully, to show differential treatment.

Pressing for a probation decision: the usual order

  1. Count the dates

    Work out the date your normal probation ended, the date double the period ends, and how much leave you took. Write these on one sheet with the orders that support them.

  2. Read the rules of your post

    Check whether the recruitment rules or service rules fix a maximum and forbid extension beyond it, and whether a test or course is a condition. This decides whether you argue for deemed confirmation or for a decision.

  3. Write to the appointing authority

    Ask for a decision on completion of probation, the reasons for each extension and copies of any adverse material. Send it through proper channel and keep the receipt.

  4. Use RTI for the record

    Ask the CPIO for the probation reports, the minutes of the board or committee that considered your case, and the note sheets leading to each extension.

  5. Answer anything adverse

    If you receive a warning or an adverse APAR, reply in writing within the time given, point by point. Keep the reply factual.

  6. Approach the tribunal if needed

    If no decision comes within a reasonable time after your representation, or the extension is plainly beyond the limits, file an Original Application. The relief sought is usually a direction to decide, or a declaration that probation stood completed where the rules support it.

The waiting rule before filing, ordinarily six months after a representation, is explained in our page on representation and Section 20.

A made-up example: a scientist in Dehradun

Here's a made-up example. Arjun joined a central research institute in Dehradun as a Scientist on direct recruitment in March 2021, with two years' probation under the recruitment rules. In April 2023 he received an order extending probation by one year, with no reasons. In April 2024 came a second extension of six months, and in October 2024 a third of six months, again without reasons.

By March 2025 he had served four years, double the normal period. He had taken no long leave, his APARs were graded 'Very Good', and the required training was complete. An RTI reply showed that the assessment board had not met after 2022 and the extension orders were issued on routine notes. He wrote to the appointing authority asking for a decision, and when six months passed without one, he filed an Original Application.

Because Uttarakhand cases now go to the Principal Bench in New Delhi, his case was filed there. The tribunal directed the department to decide on completion of his probation within a fixed time on the existing record, noting the absence of any assessment. His probation was declared complete from the end of the original period. On different rules or a different record, the result could have been otherwise.

Promotees on probation and the risk of reversion

Where the recruitment rules of a promotion post prescribe probation, the instructions say the appointing authority should assess the officer at the end of the period and either declare completion, extend probation, or revert the officer to the lower post. Reversion of a promotee for unsatisfactory work on probation is not a penalty in itself, but it must be based on an honest assessment and not used as a short cut for misconduct.

Promotees sometimes find that their probation on promotion is extended while a vigilance matter is looked into. If that matter has not reached a chargesheet, ask on what basis the probation assessment is being held up, since the sealed cover procedure has its own rules. Reversion after ad hoc promotion is a related but different situation, explained in our guide on reversion after ad hoc promotion.

Where a probation dispute is heard

Probation, confirmation and discharge of central government employees are service matters under Section 3(q) of the Administrative Tribunals Act, so they go to the Central Administrative Tribunal. The bench is generally the one within whose territory you are posted. Employees of bodies notified under Section 14(2) also go to CAT.

Employees of public sector undertakings and nationalised banks usually go to the High Court by writ, since their employers are generally outside CAT. State government employees go to the state administrative tribunal where there is one, or to the High Court. Armed forces personnel go to the Armed Forces Tribunal, and CAPF personnel generally to the High Court.

Limitation under Section 21 is one year from the final order, or one year after the six months allowed for a pending representation. Where the grievance is a continuing failure to decide, tribunals are often less strict, but an extension order you did not challenge for years can still be held against you.

Time and cost: what to plan for

StageTime range in practiceCost in general terms
Decision expected after probation endsSix to eight weeks under DoPT's instructions; often longer in practiceNo fee
Representation asking for a decision and reasonsWait up to six months before the tribunal route ordinarily opensPostage and copies
RTI for probation reports and board minutes30 days for a reply; first appeal 30 days after thatRs 10 application fee and copying charges
Original Application before CATReply and rejoinder often take three to eight months; final hearing depends on the benchA small fixed tribunal fee (Rs 50 under Rule 7 of the CAT (Procedure) Rules; ask the registry for the current figure and mode), plus copying and typing
Compliance after a tribunal directionUsually within the time fixed in the order, often two to four monthsNo fee; a contempt or execution step may be needed if ignored

Mistakes probationers make

The first is staying silent out of fear. Probationers worry that asking for a decision will annoy the reporting officer and invite a discharge. In practice a polite, factual letter asking for the status of probation is a normal request. What hurts more is an unanswered file that drifts past the double limit with no record that you ever asked.

The second is assuming automatic confirmation and acting on it, for example by applying for deputation or promotion as if confirmed. If the rules do not support deemed confirmation, such applications get rejected and can create friction. The third is ignoring a warning letter. A probationer who does not reply to a written warning leaves the department's version as the only one on the file.

Advocate B.K. Singh's second tip and what to do this week

Advocate B.K. Singh's second suggestion is to treat each extension order as a separate decision that needs its own answer. Write a short representation against each one within a few weeks of receiving it, even if you do not plan to go to the tribunal yet. It shows you objected at the time, and it keeps limitation questions simple if a discharge order follows later. If a discharge does come, our page on discharge of a probationer by a simple order explains how to test whether it was punitive.

This week, find your recruitment rules and mark the probation clause, put every extension order in date order, and list your leave and training. Then send the letter and the RTI application described above. If you suspect a complaint lies behind the extensions, say so in your letter and ask whether any inquiry is pending, because the line between an extension and a disguised penalty is thin.

For advice on your own papers or updates on changes to the probation instructions, you can contact Advocate B.K. Singh.

Frequently asked questions

How many times can my probation be extended in central government?

There is no fixed number of extensions, but DoPT's instructions say each extension should normally be no more than a year, and total probation should never go beyond double the normal period. Each extension should follow an actual review of your work. Repeated extensions without reasons can be questioned.

My probation period ended months ago and I have no order. Am I confirmed?

Usually not. DoPT's instructions say confirmation needs a formal order and you continue on probation until then. Deemed confirmation arises mainly where your service rules fix a maximum period and forbid extension beyond it.

Can maternity leave be used to extend my probation?

Yes, within limits. Under the OM of 5 October 2017, if leave of any kind stopped you completing 75 per cent of your probation, it can be extended by the length of the leave, but not beyond double the normal period. Check that only the leave actually taken has been added.

Do I need to be confirmed again after promotion?

No. DoPT's instructions say confirmation happens only once in service, in the entry grade. A promotion post may have its own probation if the recruitment rules prescribe it, but that is assessed separately.

Should I have received a warning before my probation was extended?

The instructions say a probationer not progressing well should be warned in writing and given time to improve. An extension without any warning or adverse record is harder for a department to justify. Ask for the reasons and the reports in writing.

Can the department discharge me after keeping me on probation for years?

It can discharge a probationer whose work is unsatisfactory, but the discharge must be based on an honest assessment. If it is really founded on misconduct, an inquiry is needed. Take advice quickly if a discharge order arrives.

Does delayed confirmation affect my promotion?

It can. Some recruitment rules make completion of probation a condition for departmental exams or for promotion. Check the rules of the next post and raise the delay early so a promotion cycle is not missed.

Where do I file a case about probation extension?

Central government employees go to the Central Administrative Tribunal bench where they are posted. PSU and bank employees usually go to the High Court. State government employees go to the state tribunal or the High Court.

Advocate B.K. Singh

Advocate B.K. Singh

Founder of B.K. Singh & Associates. MCA, LL.B., LL.M. More than twenty years in practice before the Supreme Court, the Delhi High Court and other High Courts, the Central Administrative Tribunal and other tribunals. This guide was written and reviewed by his team.

This guide explains the law in general terms and is not legal advice. For advice on your own papers, contact the team.

Have a service dispute with the department?

Share the order, charge memo or pension papers with our advocates. You will learn the time limit that applies to you and the step to take first.

Book Consultation Call +91 96259 61599
WhatsApp us